Marsden Hartley was a bold and enigmatic figure in American Modernism, a painter whose work shifted between abstraction, symbolism, and landscape with a deeply personal intensity. Emerging in the early 20th century alongside modernist pioneers, Hartley drew inspiration from European avant-garde movements, absorbing elements of Cubism, German Expressionism, and Fauvism. Yet, his art remained distinctly his own; imbued with raw emotion, vibrant colour, and a deep engagement with both spiritual themes and the American landscape. From his early abstract compositions to later still life and maritime paintings, Hartley’s style evolved continuously, reflecting both his restless travels and personal struggles.

This post explores five key works that showcase Hartley’s rich artistic range, from his symbolic abstractions to his meditative still life compositions. Whether inspired by the bold geometry of German military pageantry, the mysticism of Catholic iconography, or the rugged beauty of coastal New England, Hartley’s paintings defy easy categorisation. These pieces not only highlight his unique vision but also cement his legacy as one of the most original voices in American art.

...

Lobster on a Black Background, by Marsden Hartley

1. Lobster on a Black Background (1940-41)

In 1937, after years of extensive travel, Marsden Hartley returned to his native Maine, where he would spend the remainder of his life. This period marked a profound reconnection with his roots, inspiring a series of works that encapsulate the state’s rugged landscapes and maritime culture. Among these is the striking still life, Lobster on Black Background (1940–1941), which exemplifies Hartley’s deep affinity for Maine’s coastal life. 

The painting features a solitary, vividly red lobster set against a stark black backdrop. This composition highlights Hartley’s fascination with form and realism, presenting the lobster with crisp outlines and direct simplicity. The choice of subject matter reflects Maine’s fishing industry, while the minimalist approach underscores the artist’s modernist sensibilities. Created during a time when Hartley’s health was in decline, the artwork also conveys a sense of introspection and a return to simpler, more personal themes.

Lobster on Black Background stands as a testament to Hartley’s ability to fuse regional subject matter with modernist aesthetics, capturing the essence of Maine’s identity through a contemporary lens.

Roses for Seagulls That Lost Their Way, by Marsden Hartley

2. Roses for Seagulls That Lost Their Way (1935-36)

Marsden Hartley’s Roses for Seagulls That Lost Their Way (1935–1936) is an evocative example of his symbolic and emotionally charged still life paintings. Painted during a turbulent period in his life, the work features a bouquet of sixteen white roses, tied with a delicate ribbon, set against an intensely red background. The stark contrast between the flowers and the backdrop heightens the painting’s emotional weight, while the flat, modernist composition strips the subject of any decorative excess, reducing it to its essential form. Hartley’s use of bold colour and simplified structure echoes the influences of European avant-garde movements, but the personal symbolism within the work remains uniquely his own.

The title itself—both poetic and melancholic—hints at themes of loss, longing, and spiritual searching. Hartley painted this piece during his second trip to Bermuda, where he sought solace from both personal grief and artistic frustrations. Later, he carried the painting to Nova Scotia, an indication of its significance within his body of work. The roses, often associated with remembrance and mourning, may serve as a tribute to lost companions or an expression of his own sense of isolation. This piece exemplifies Hartley’s ability to merge abstraction with deep emotion, creating a work that is at once visually striking and profoundly introspective.

Painting No. 48, by Marsden Hartley

3. Painting No. 48 (1913)

Marsden Hartley’s Painting No. 48 (1913) is one of the most striking examples of his engagement with abstract symbolism during his time in Berlin. A chaotic yet carefully structured arrangement of bold geometric forms, primary colours, and dynamic patterns, the piece reflects Hartley’s deep fascination with German military pageantry. The central motif, a prominent black oval containing the number “8”, suggests an emblematic insignia, reminiscent of military badges and regalia. The interplay of red, blue, and yellow against darker tones creates an almost pulsating effect, heightening the painting’s sense of movement and intensity.

During his stay in Berlin, Hartley was deeply influenced by the spectacle of military parades and nationalistic displays. His work from this period incorporated the visual language of banners, medals, and insignias, translating them into his own unique form of modernist abstraction. Painting No. 48 is not simply a decorative arrangement of forms—it is a coded language, reflecting both the power and the fragility of identity in a rapidly shifting world. Created just before World War I, the painting takes on a prophetic undertone, its militaristic imagery hinting at the looming global conflict. Today, it remains one of Hartley’s most iconic works of early American abstraction, housed in the Brooklyn Museum in New York.

The Virgin of Guadalupe, by Marsden Hartley

4. The Virgin of Guadalupe (c. 1918-19)

After returning to the United States from Germany, Marsden Hartley ventured to New Mexico, where he became enamoured with the Spanish Colonial, Mexican, and Indigenous arts of the region. This period marked a significant shift in his artistic focus, as he began to explore religious iconography, particularly that of the Virgin of Guadalupe. His painting, The Virgin of Guadalupe (circa 1918–1919), depicts a bulto, a small carved and painted religious statue, likely based on a specific example of the Virgin Mary to which he had access.  The composition reflects Hartley’s deep appreciation for the directness and sincerity of these traditional religious artefacts.

In this work, Hartley employs vibrant colours and simplified forms, capturing the essence of the folk art aesthetic. The Virgin is portrayed with a serene expression, adorned in a richly coloured mantle, standing against a plain background that emphasizes her presence. This painting not only showcases Hartley’s ability to adapt and reinterpret traditional religious imagery but also highlights his ongoing quest for spiritual meaning through art. By integrating elements of Spanish Colonial and Indigenous art, Hartley created a piece that resonates with cultural significance, reflecting his deep connection to the American Southwest and its artistic heritage.

Berlin Series No. 1, by Marsden Hartley

5. Berlin Series No. 1 (1913)

Berlin Series No. 1 (1913) marks a pivotal moment in Marsden Hartley’s artistic journey, reflecting his immersion into European modernism during his time in Berlin. This painting showcases Hartley’s exploration of abstraction, influenced by his exposure to avant-garde movements and his fascination with Native American imagery. The composition features bold geometric forms and vibrant colours, including reds, yellows, and greens, set against a flat black background. These elements evoke symbols such as birds, cornstalks, and teepees, indicating Hartley’s appropriation of Native American motifs. 

During this period, Hartley was deeply influenced by the dynamic cultural environment of Berlin, which exposed him to various artistic styles and ethnographic collections. His fascination with Native American artefacts, encountered in European museums, led him to incorporate these symbols into his work, aiming to establish a distinct American identity within the modernist movement. Berlin Series No. 1 exemplifies this synthesis, blending indigenous American symbolism with European abstraction. This painting is part of a series of four works, all sharing similar dimensions and subject matter, created around the same time. The series represents Hartley’s efforts to merge his American heritage with the contemporary artistic expressions he encountered abroad, contributing to his unique position within the early 20th-century art scene. 

...

Marsden Hartley remains one of the most distinctive voices in American modernism, a painter who constantly reinvented himself while staying deeply connected to personal, cultural, and spiritual themes. His works—whether inspired by Maine’s maritime life, European abstraction, Native American iconography, or religious devotion—demonstrate an artist always searching for a greater meaning beyond the visible world. From the bold symbolism of the Berlin Series to the meditative stillness of his later Maine works, Hartley’s evolution as a painter reflects both his restless spirit and his deeply felt artistic convictions.

By blending elements of Cubism, Expressionism, and American folk traditions, Hartley carved a unique path that defied easy categorisation. Today, his paintings continue to inspire collectors, artists, and scholars alike, proving that his exploration of form, colour, and identity remains as relevant and thought-provoking as ever.